Wills & Estates · July 2026

Testamentary Capacity in Victoria

By Peter McLeod · 6 min read

A senior reviewing their will with a lawyer, exploring testamentary capacity in Victoria

A Will is only as strong as the capacity of the person who made it. In Victoria, a Will can be challenged if the will-maker did not have testamentary capacity when they signed it. For families across Melbourne’s northern suburbs, understanding what that means can be the difference between an estate that passes smoothly and one that ends up in dispute.

What is testamentary capacity?

Testamentary capacity is the legal term for the mental ability a person needs to make a valid Will. It is not the same as being able to manage day-to-day affairs. A person can be elderly, frail, or living with some cognitive decline and still have capacity to make a Will, provided they meet the legal test at the time they give instructions and sign.

The Banks v Goodfellow test

Victorian courts still apply the test set out in the 1870 case Banks v Goodfellow. To have testamentary capacity, the will-maker must:

  • understand that they are making a Will and what it does;
  • understand, in general terms, the nature and extent of their property;
  • appreciate the claims of those who might reasonably expect to benefit, such as a spouse or children; and
  • not be affected by any disorder of the mind or delusion that influences how they dispose of their estate.

Formal requirements for a valid Will in Victoria

Capacity is only one part of a valid Will. Under the Wills Act 1997 (Vic), a Will must generally be in writing, made by a person aged 18 or over, signed by the will-maker (or by someone at their direction in their presence), and witnessed by two people who are present at the same time and who also sign. Getting these formalities wrong is one of the most common reasons a Will is later challenged.

When capacity is most often questioned

Capacity disputes tend to arise where a Will was made late in life, changed suddenly, signed shortly before death, or made while the will-maker was unwell or dependent on a beneficiary. Where there are suspicious circumstances, the person putting the Will forward may have to prove that the will-maker knew and approved of its contents.

How a wills lawyer helps protect a Will

A wills lawyer in Melbourne can reduce the risk of a later challenge by taking instructions directly from the will-maker alone, keeping detailed file notes, arranging a medical assessment of capacity where there is any doubt, and making sure the formalities are met. Together these steps create a contemporaneous record that is difficult to dispute.

If you are worried about a Will

If you are concerned that a family member made or changed a Will without capacity, or you are an executor facing a challenge, early advice matters. Strict time limits apply to contesting a Will or a deceased estate in Victoria, so it is best to speak with a wills and estates lawyer promptly.

Key takeaways

  • Capacity is judged at the time the Will is made, not by age or general health.
  • Victoria still applies the Banks v Goodfellow test for testamentary capacity.
  • Careful, well-documented instructions from a wills lawyer help a Will withstand challenge.

Related services

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. It does not take account of your particular circumstances. For advice about your matter, please contact Buller McLeod Lawyers on (03) 9306 4000.

Speak with a wills lawyer in Melbourne

Speak with Peter McLeod about your matter. Book a confidential consultation at our Glenroy office or by video.

Send an enquiry
  • DIRECT LINE

    (03) 9306 4000
  • OUR ADDRESS

    14 Post Office Pl, Glenroy VIC 3046